Central Saanich resident Liz Mueller wrote to Premier
Christy Clark and here was the Premier's response - or
at least the response of someone in her office:
Dec. 5:
We understand that
this is a very important issue for your and your
neighbours.
As you may be aware, on August 20, 2013, the CRD
suspended the licence issued to Stanhope Dairy Farm and
applicable to the Foundation Organics Ltd. composting
facility. The CRD is currently reviewing the
revised Operating Plan submitted by Foundation Organics,
and they are committed to resolving the odour issue for
the residents of the surrounding area.
Stanhope Dairy Farm is currently operating as a Class 1
Composting Facility, as opposed to a Class 3 which was
their previous operating capacity. The matter is
still being reviewed prior to the suspension being
lifted. We would encourage you to keep working
with local government, and to send comments to the CRD
odour complaint forum.
We hope this information is helpful and we wish you all
the best over the Holiday Season.
Liz's letter:
After many hours of meetings with
local politicians, it was anticipated the offending smell would be,
and must be, stopped.
But as of today, Stanhope Dairy Farm is still composting and
creating the most abhorrent smell imaginable affecting hundreds
of people's right to enjoy their property and neighbourhoods.
It seriously affects people's health and well-being and has
definitely affected our property values. No one wants to
visit us, let alone buy our house!
It is time the Premier did a review of why so many ministries,
the CRD and agencies are totally unable to stop it from
continuing despite what appears to be an arsenal of sanctions at
their disposal in umpteen different statutes.
October 2013
Tried "Wrong Industry-Wrong Location"
Now It's Time to Do It Right!
Rather than the fragmented, piece-meal approach
taken so far, the CRD needs to look at planning for the
future in a much more integrated way. The RITE Plan
advocates (including CRD Director Vic Derman) have viable
ideas that should form part of the discussion. Why
isn't the CRD paying attention?
Stanhope Farm is not, never was,
and never will be a good site for such a facility! My hope
and aim in the continuing battle is to see the composting
facility at Stanhope Farm PERMANENTLY shut down. We should
be pushing for a CRD composting facility to be built -
perhaps located at Hartland - which will process the
region's solid waste in an anaerobic digester
system. Central Saanich's ALR land should remain as arable
land!
Kirsty Williams
September 2013
Possible Animal Abuse:
Are Pigs Being Fed to Pigs?
Sept. 3 from Mayor Bryson:
"I would request that Central Saanich staff follow up on the allegation that collected food waste
(Ed. note: cruise ship food waste
includes pork products) is being used as livestock food on this farm. I would ask that staff please inquire with the Canadian Food Inspection Agency
or other appropriate body regarding the legality of such a practice.
I would also request that Central Saanich staff follow up with the Ministry
of the Environment to inquire whether the farm can legitimately
accept food waste (for any purpose) under the OMRR regulations
while their recycler license is suspended. Also if the food
waste is being stockpiled what is the Ministry of the
Environment doing to monitor the quantity, storage of the
material and whether it poses a risk to the environment."
"Plastic Compost" Sold?
How "Green" Was the Compost?
The photos above were taken of one
of the Foundation Organics fields in September. The
plastic needs to
be picked up by hand because it won't integrate into the soil.
Is this the kind of "compost" we want near our food?
Sept. 26: Just going outside right now to
harvest some plastic...
The area I am 'harvesting' from is approx. 2' by
6'. I've taken pictures of what I've picked JUST from
the surface so far, I haven't disturbed the surface (I'm
using my bonsai tweezers) at all yet and this is what
I've gotten so far. Keep in mind that this is made
up of 3 parts soil/ 1 part sand/ and ONLY 1 part
compost...even I'm shocked at what is coming out of
here. It's all evenly shredded up so you can tell it's
been processed by the shredders.
We found out that the soil/compost/sand mix we
purchased last month had compost from FO in it. I
purchased it at Aces Gravel Mart. I phoned to
confirm this, and yes, they were in fact getting compost
from FO but not any longer.
(Ed: So was this compost
removed from the FO property and sold to Aces? Such an
action, if it occurred, would have been in direct contravention of Central Saanich's
bylaw.)
We knew something was funny when we handled it with our
bare hands; it was like handling charcoal turning our
hands black. Soil doesn't do that. After it
settled for a couple of weeks, the plastic started
coming up. Doesn't make me feel very good!
Karen Long
If the water that comes out of our taps in
the Capital Region smelled as bad as the air at my daughter's house
on Twin View Place in Central Saanich you would be obliged to issue
an advisory, via the media, to caution people to boil the water or
not to drink it because it could be potentially unhealthy.
My daughter has three children aged three, five, and seven.
I worry about them having to live in that environment.
Frequently, they cannot even play in their own yard because the
smell in the air is so offensive and possibly dangerous to their
health. They even have to close the windows on some nice days.
That is not fair, at all, for the children or anyone else.
There are people in the Tanner Ridge area who feel that their
illnesses are a direct result of the airborne particles that
are causing the offensive smells. Would you consider warning
people about the problem, via the media, while you continue to
investigate the health implications of the poor air quality in the
Tanner Ridge area? The air that we breath is every bit
as important as the water that we drink.
Len Box
More Government Indifference
Sept. 30: Ministry of
Environment's Conrad Berube's Response to a Letter from a
Central Saanich Resident
The ST/FO facility has an odour
management plan in place which was developed by Dr. John Paul,
of Transform Compost Systems Ltd. Dr. Paul has indicated
that he was on site at the facility in mid-July and made
recommendations to address odour issues (which have since been
implemented). The operators at the facility have been
cooperative
with the Ministry in trying to
address any perceived deficiency in complying with our
legislation.
Although
operators continue to experience challenges in this regard,
recent court cases have indicated that in order for the province
to demonstrate that odours are causing pollution they must be
shown to be producing a physiological impact (a physically
measurable affect - a physiological consequence - something that
causes a real physical suffering, an objective rather than a
subjective experience). A subjective complaint that an
odour is unpleasant is not sufficient to meet evidentiary
standards. That being the case, a conservation
officer attended the site on August 10, 2013 for roughly an
hour. He reported a smell consistent with manure on a farm
(which would not constitute a non-compliance to OMRR) and
reported that he not express [sic] any physical responses to the
exposure. Similarly, a VIHA representative has been
on adjoining property on a number of occasions and indicates
that there is no empirical evidence for health allegations that
complainants are reporting. Likewise, WorkSafeBC
investigation did not result in any gas or odour related
findings.
This prompted a spirited response from the
recipient!
Your assertions that
professionals have been involved both in the designing of the filter
system at Foundation Organics and in trying to remedy the horrendous
and obvious flaws in the original design provide zero consolation to
the residents of Tanner Ridge and Martindale Valley. We have been
choking on the daily disgusting odours produced by this facility for
months, and despite the assertions of the individual inspector you
referenced, there is an entire neighbourhood who will very decidedly
tell you that this odour does NOT smell like compost. I have a
compost pile in my backyard that I cannot smell at all. The odours
produced by this facility have variously resembled vomit,
putrefaction, and just plain garbage.
As to your assertions that these
odours are simply odours and have not produced health problems, I
know a great number of the residents of Central Saanich who
would again strongly and heartily disagree with you on this point as
well. Among those would be a resident who has no olfactory
sense at all (and counted himself lucky among his neighbours) until
after protracted exposure to the stench, he found himself repeatedly
vomiting up his breakfast on a daily basis. Another would be
my own husband who is suffering from the first sinus infection he
can ever recall suffering in his life - at the age of 55.
He contracted this infection at the beginning of May, and has been
on several courses of antibiotics and steroidal nasal sprays.
Tomorrow is the first of October and he is still suffering with this
infection. Other neighbours have complained of other sinus and
respiratory effects (strangely alleviated by holidays away from
Central Saanich) - and this has been testified to and documented by
the District of Central Saanich and to the Capital Regional District
as well. Our demands for action on identifying the causal
organisms of our community's illnesses have so far fallen on deaf
ears, and it appears you seem to be a little hard of hearing
yourself.
Andree Penrice
Sept. 26:
To Don Hubbard,
Chair,
Island Health Board of Directors
Dr. Stanwick, who is the
designate Chief Medical Health Officer for the area, has
failed to respond, either privately or publicly, to many
concerned Central Saanich residents who have sought his
expertise and intervention in the matter of Foundation
Organics and the plume of off-gasses which they have allowed
to escape in contravention of CRD bylaws for many months. We
have asked him more than a dozen times since June to
determine through either an air quality study or other
methods whether
or not residents of the Tanner Ridge area were breathing
toxic substances contained in the noxious cloud which has
covered our lives for over a year.
Oct. 2 Follow-up:
Sir, there are more than 2500 people who have lived with
the stench (and who know what else, as no one will order testing)
from Foundation Organics for nearly two full years. All we
want is an honest discussion. One of the reasons that I am
involved in this issue is I cannot help but feel that we are being
treated as second class here for reasons that elude me entirely.
We are ignored, more than one hundred of our letters have all gone
unanswered. A “form letter” which incredibly managed to contradict
itself was deemed sufficient for us. Yet when a colleague of
your Dr Stanwick raised well-known, but un-documented issues in
relation to a different composting facility –one which did NOT
contain animal products- Dr. Stanwick responded with a
strongly-worded letter to the local authorities, a letter which was
also circulated to the media at the time. Without performing so much
as a single air quality test, Dr. Stanwick cited his colleague’s
research and requested the assistance of the Town of View Royal in
dealing with the matter.
Kevin Fry
I am writing to express my disappointment and distress
with regard to the attitude expressed by you and the Health
Administration in general with regard to our insistence that the
off-gassing from Foundation Organics was making us sick.
I would like you to imagine that you have come to work and said
to your boss that you are feeling sick and that you think it
might be due to the noxious air quality in your neighborhood. He
then says that he doubts that could be so. You further inform
him of your symptoms and how really rough you are feeling and he
looks you over and says, "Well, how sick are you really? You are
here after all. Have you had formal proof of illness? And what
makes you think that it has anything to do with the noxious
odors enveloping your neighborhood?" You tell him that your
neighbors are exhibiting similar symptoms. He shakes his head
dismissively and tells you that he, in fact, talked to your
community and there is nothing to suggest that you are really
sick or that the air quality would have anything to do with it
in any case. Probably you just don’t like the nuisance smell.
That, by the way, is exactly how dismissive you sound to us.
This is not worthy of you as a human being and it is certainly
not worthy of someone in your position.
I ask you: What if this same stench were enveloping the
hospitals in our region and the patients and medical staff were
struggling to breathe deeply—those with compromised lungs were
now needing assistance, those with asthma were having to
increase their medications and restrict their time outside? You
start to see sinus infections, skin rashes, and allergy
reactions that are new, non-stop headaches, and even phantom
toothaches are finally examined with CT scans only to discover
there is nothing wrong with the tooth in question. Then you
notice that so many in the hospital are coughing and yet they
don’t have a cold. So—after witnessing all this, would you tell
all those patients and medical staff that there is no reason to
assume that they are sick, as such? It is only an odour
after all. Or would you make it your business to get involved in
exploring the situation properly and in shutting that stench
down permanently? I doubt very much that you would allow this
type of facility to be in the airshed of a hospital. Why should
it be in the airshed of anyone?
We had a new born baby come home from the hospital on July 30th when
the stench was at an all time high, and that poor little fellow
did not have a clean breath of air in his own home for the next
two weeks. In fact he didn’t have a clean breath of air until he
ended up back in the hospital for a week. Fortunately when he
returned home Foundation Organics was on suspension so the
stench was now intermittent and the off gassing was not as
severe, however we are all living in dread that it will resume.
So if I have made this letter sound a little personal I will
excuse myself by suggesting that it IS very personal to all of
us.
If you spoke with someone in Central Saanich about this
situation I can only suggest that it was not with someone who
lives in my area. I know how I was feeling this summer and
exactly how I feel when that putrid off gassing fills my home
even temporarily now.
Brenda Antonson
My question to you, Dr.
Stanwick, is simple: Why hasn't VIHA joined forces with
the Ministry of Health and the Environment Ministry to do
full-scale air quality testing on any day when the plant's been
operational? This business is sited in the midst of farmland,
residences and a recreational trail, and our elementary school
is just over a kilometre away from it, so thousands of the
residents in our community have been exposed to this foul air.
Have you not been concerned, or at least even a little curious
about what's in the plume?
I expected more regulation before this industrial operation was
ever allowed to set up shop; I expected more oversight from you
and your fellow government bodies once it was.
Sadly, I - and my community - have been let down.
Dolores Bell
Everyone who has experienced any health concerns possibly
relating to this situation should all be contacting VIHA
individually and we should also send letters to the Central
Saanich council in order for them to be taken into consideration
in their formal letter to VIHA/ Environment. It was rather
eye-opening to me to hear about some of the other health
concerns that others are experiencing. My husband has had a
sinus infection since the beginning of May that hasn't been able
to be resolved despite several courses of antibiotics and
steroidal nasal sprays.
Andree Penrice
Through this “stop the stink” journey, it has surfaced
that numerous people are having health issues that they feel are
directly correlated to the air pollutants that are occurring
from Foundations Organics.
My husband ended up at his doctor’s office with an eye infection
in both eyes. He had washed all the back yard outdoor
furniture and the next morning woke up with very irritated
eyes. After dialogue with the doctor regarding the operations
going on at Foundations Organics, and his query surrounding his
eyes, she was very concerned and did concur that his eye
infections could be from an environmental pollutant. She has
provided him with a medication and wants to see him back in two
weeks.
It has also been brought to our attention that sinus infections,
runny eyes, breathing issues, irritating cough, sore throats,
people with asthma and other lung related issues are having to
increase their medications, aching of teeth, headaches, ear
aches and missed employment have all occurred due to the “stink”
situation we currently are enduring.
Concerned Resident
As some neighbours of Foundation Organics point out: “This is a positive step but let’s not forget that one of the operators of this garbage dump has a trucking company, Finish Line Trucking, and these trucks are also being used to haul garbage to FO. This is not over by a long shot. This past weekend we had three cruise ships in port on Friday starting at 4:30 p.m. and two more at 6:00 p.m. On Saturday we had four cruise ships in port, the first of these arrived at 8:00 a.m., the other three arrived in the evening with the first two at 6:00 p.m. and the last at 7:00 p.m. All of these ships had garbage to unload in Victoria.”
Dave and Michele Bond live at “Ground Zero” near the waste plant. They sent the following information in an email to the CRD Bylaw Enforcement Officer: “We rounded out the day counting about 18 dump truck loads of fill that we personally witnessed….and we undoubtedly missed some. Added to this was some wood waste (Ellice) and food waste (the cruise ships)…so it was a very busy day. Surely this “rogue filling” of ALR and Central Saanich land just for pure profit for a “pseudo farmer” cannot be permitted or tolerated. And of course the odour persists because they are still composting in spite of direct CRD orders to stop.”
If we continue to apply pressure on all sides whether
regulatory or client/supplier, the community pressure will have this
kind of effect on others equally concerned about their reputation.
Can we dare to hope that if we can't shut them down within the
regulatory environment that we can make it economically
unsustainable for them to continue operating?
Angie Rashbrook
I'll drink my toast to Tervita
and the tireless folks fighting this battle who have never given up!
Rose
Davidson
Mayor Bryson,
Just back from a visit to Stanhope with Frans Winkel.
Our visit was prompted by yet another delivery
of cruise ship waste. The forklift operator said that it was "pig food".
A semi-trailer load of food waste for seven pigs....yes it's now down to seven,
and a similar delivery was made yesterday at 3:38 PM. This so patently
ridiculous that it defies belief that it is allowed to continue.
I can confirm that CRD bylaw staff were on site to witness and photograph the delivery,
but this is not good enough.....they should be STOPPING IT.
Each delivery adds to the time we neighbours must endure the stench. This is not acceptable.
David Bond
Sept. 7