Did You Know?
September 7:
ALC Tribunal Upholds Validity of Stop
Work Order
The Agricultural Land Commission’s
decision on the appeal by Stanhope/Foundation
Organics of the January 30, 2014 Stop Work Order
(SWO) has just been released.
The Tribunal has determined that the SWO was
indeed
“based on
sound and reasoned findings” and that CEO Mr. Richard Bullock and staff acted
appropriately. The Commissioners do not
agree with submissions by the Appellants and the
self-styled “Central Saanich Community” to the
contrary.
The Commissioners have ruled that
they’re bound by the Act and were therefore
unable to consider issues related to noise,
smell and traffic. But they note that
“very few concrete
numbers”
have been provided
and that
“not
all questions and concerns…have been answered”
by the Appellants.
They recognize that the scale and scope of
operations at Stanhope have changed, and state
that any compost or importation of farm inputs
“must be necessary
for a farm use and commensurate to the size and
scale of the farm.”
“Based on the evidence before them, the Appeal
Commissioners refuse to grant the relief sought”
by the Appellants to reverse the SWO.
Instead, they have referred the matter back to
the CEO with directions to review the Order,
consider the change in operations, and determine
whether the SWO should be altered or rescinded.
August 25:
A Case of Deja Vu
A noble cause (in
theory) has been accompanied by the ignoring of
Municipal bylaws and the causing of distress for
neighbours, and the creation of environmental
problems. Legal guns have been called in,
followed by efforts to enlist the loud support
of people who don’t live anywhere near the
facility. If it feels like we’ve seen all
this before, we have, only this time we’re
referring to Woodwynn Farms.
A resident of Central Saanich, a volunteer
chaplain working with the homeless and those in
rehab, stated that it’s incumbent upon good
service providers to
“help restore people to
a place that they can be active responsible
law-abiding citizens. The service agency
has a responsibility to model this themselves.
Unfortunately over the last several years,
Woodwynn Farm’s actions have given the message
that if the bylaw doesn’t fit, either ignore or
break it.”
Another Central Saanich resident wrote:
“The
operator show[s] a sense of entitlement which
can be distilled down to a single phrase – ‘I
want to, therefore I can.’”
Woodwynn has
mounted a social media campaign to pressure our
Municipality into dropping its court action and
changing its course – a course clearly outlined
in our bylaws, which supposedly apply to us
all. Council has received emails of support for
Woodwynn’s rogue direction from people who live
most anywhere
but
in Central Saanich.
The similarities between the Woodwynn situation
and our experience with the composting operation
are striking.
August 6:
The Truth is Incontrovertible – Part 2
A U.S. judge recently imposed a $1.3 billion
penalty against Bank of America (BAC) for its
role in selling risky mortgages – a practice BAC
knew to be wrong. The judge stated that
the Bank was “driven by a hunger for profits
and oblivious to the harms thereby visited.”
We find this wilful blindness repeated again and
again, sadly even
close to home.
The CRD, the ALC and our District of
Central Saanich (in other words, taxpayers) have
spent major resources trying to bring Foundation
Organics into compliance with bylaws and
regulations – the same rules that were in place
before their composting licence was even issued
- and, finally, to try to stop the prohibited
activities entirely.
Yet the documentation provided to the ALC’s
Tribunal in June showed that those laws were
largely disregarded.
For the
lengthy, sorry catalogue of mistreatment of
Stanhope’s neighbours and of our bylaws -
including commercial trucking operations, middle
of the night wood-waste grinding noise, massive
truck traffic, pet aquamation and, of course,
the atrocious compost stench – as recorded by
our Municipality’s Bylaw Enforcement Officer,
read the full affidavit and log:
https://www.dropbox.com/s/1bkje095nyiiuye/DCS%20Bylaw%20Officer%20Affidavit%20and%20Log.pdf
Sample Log Entries:
June 24, 2013:
“They…stated that
we may as well start issuing tickets because
they have no intention to pay the tickets
anyways – they’ll just forward the tickets to
[their lawyer] to dispute them.”
September 4, 2013:
“Matt
Mansell confirmed that they are continuing to
receive food waste from the cruise ships and are
feeding it to the seven pigs that they have
on-site. Mr. Mansell agreed that seven
pigs can’t eat a semi-truck full of food waste
daily.”
October 17, 2013:
You’ll
have to read about this temper tantrum
yourselves!
“The truth is
incontrovertible.
Malice may attack it,
ignorance may deride it,
but in the end, there
it is.”
-
Winston Churchill
July 29:
The Truth is Incontrovertible - Part 1
While we wait for the ALC's Tribunal to make its
determination, we have interesting reading in the
thousands of pages of evidence submitted to the
Commissioners last month. One document among
the many that stand out is the Affidavit and
Activity Log kept by Ken Neurauter, our Central
Saanich Bylaw Enforcement Officer. This log,
up to May of this year, ran to 250 pages with all
the supporting evidence.
In it, we have confirmation that the District of
Central Saanich advised Stanhope in December 2010
that the commercial sale of compost wasn't permitted
under Bylaw 1309. In January 2011, the FO
operators submitted a Revised Operating Plan
claiming that all composted material would be used
on Stanhope land. Yet there were
confirmed reports as early as June 2011 that compost
was being sold to Peninsula Landscaping, and then to
Trio, Marigold, Kimoff, Arbutus Grove, Tervita, the
Songhees Reserve and DND (as well as to Aces, from
resident accounts), in spite of denials by the
Stanhope/Foundation Organics operators.
The documentation shows that compost sales were
still ongoing in
May
of this year.
Log Entry, May 7,
2014:
“[Kimoff
owner] met me at the compost pile and also
confirmed that they had just bought 140 yards of
compost material from Foundation Organics.”
Our great thanks to Ken Neurauter for his detailed,
professional work and to our Mayor, Councillors and
our District Administration for their past and
ongoing work to uphold our bylaws.July 14:
CRD Litigation Delayed
http://www.cfax1070.com/News/Top-Stories/CRD-compost-trial-hits-snag
Section 6.1 of the CRD Bylaw
No. 2736 governing composting facilities states:
"No discharger shall operate a …composting facility
in a manner that creates or results in litter, dust
(spores or other particulates,
odours or vectors so as
to pose a risk to public health or the environment
or
constitute a public nuisance."
Yet an
application by Foundation Organics Ltd., Foundation
Organics Ltd. dba
Stanhope Dairy Farm, Mathew Mandell and Robert
Rendle to have the charges dismissed on the grounds
that the CRD did not have jurisdiction to regulate
public nuisances was heard earlier this month in
Provincial Court. The argument was that the
jurisdiction is with the Province pursuant to the
regulation of air contaminants and pollution within
the Environmental Management Act; and further that
the District of Central Saanich has jurisdiction
over public nuisance, not the CRD.
There was an issue as to the ramifications of the
charges while the licence was suspended, but that
argument will be left for another day. The
recycler's licence was suspended and not revoked and
Foundation Organics Ltd. continued composting during
this timeframe and failed to comply with the initial
order granted in August to stop composting food
waste and then failed to comply with the order to
remove the existing compost that was made by the CRD
on October 11, 2013.
The Provincial Court
Judge raised an issue as to whether the Provincial
Court has jurisdiction to declare a bylaw invalid
and sought submissions from counsel. After
hearing from counsel, the Judge stated words to the
effect that he was not certain if the Provincial
Court had jurisdiction and referred the matter to
the Supreme Court on this issue.
Foundation Organics Ltd., if they want to proceed
with this defence, will now have to apply to the
Supreme Court for a determination on the validity of
the bylaw. Depending on when and if Foundation
Organics Ltd. determines they want to proceed with
their challenge to the bylaw, the process, once they
have filed a Petition in the Supreme Court, will
take at least 6 months before the matter can return
to the Provincial Court for the trial on the charges
laid.
As the above-noted CFAX
report states:
“One practical effect of the
decision is another delay in concluding the matter.”
And we ask:
Who benefits from any
delay?
It wouldn’t be in the best
interests of the Applicants, Stanhope Farm/Foundation
Organics, would it?
July 10:
Here We Go Again - Central Saanich as The Wild
West
http://www.timescolonist.com/news/local/central-saanich-files-civil-claim-to-shut-down-woodwynn-farms-1.1200382
This all sounds so bizarrely familiar:
Someone whose land is in the ALR decides to go
rogue, ignore bylaws and the rest of the community,
and thumb his nose at everyone. For once we’re
not referring to Stanhope Farms and Foundation
Organics.
Woodwynn Farms tried to rezone their property
for commercial or institutional uses - to allow
dormitories, a retail market, a craft workshop,
museum and gallery, a restaurant and café, kitchen
and dining hall, an outdoor market and a performance
stage. Did they leave
anything
out?
The District of Central Saanich denied their
rezoning application, so Woodwynn applied to the ALC
for a non-farm use classification – and was refused.
But did that stop them? No. They went
ahead and “developed the property for non-farm use
including a residential program, offices, staff
housing, a coffee shop, retail store and a yoga
studio,” plus allowed recreational vehicles, mobile
homes, tents and outhouses – and ran afoul of B.C.
Building Codes as well.
In the case of Woodwynn, their motives may be
noble, but the route they’ve taken certainly isn’t.
Where do some people get the idea that rules don’t
apply to them? To quote Esquimalt’s Mayor Barb
Desjardins, “I don’t understand what you’re not
understanding and how you are wishing to subvert a
normal process.”
July 9:
The
ALC Appeal Hearing Official Transcript
The June 19 Appeal Hearing concluded early, but
still generated a lengthy official transcript.
For those who weren't able to attend the Hearing,
here are the full 111 pages of the document:
https://www.dropbox.com/s/c3kbcf44qjczp69/ALC%20Appeal%20Hearing%20Transcript%20-%20June%2019%2C%202014.pdf
Some Highlights:
Ray Baker:
“In a
letter from Stanhope’s law firm, the firm states
that some of the documentation is not available.
They claim that the farm has an “Organic” style of
record keeping. I asked two separate accountants if
they had ever heard of this “organic record
keeping.” Neither one had so I could not find a
definition for organic record keeping. My best guess
would be that the basic principle is that if you
don’t keep good records you don’t have to produce
good records.”
Michele Bond:
“Since Foundation
Organics partnered with Stanhope, there has been a
history of non-compliance with the rules and
regulations that govern this operation. The ALC Act,
Central Saanich bylaws and the CRD bylaws have
all been violated to a large degree and we have
been a direct witness to these violations.”
Rebecca Cotterell:
“Whether by inexperience or poor management, the
composting facility consistently failed to meet
bylaw regulations with regard to litter, odour and
vector; and so doing, grievously trespassed on the
property rights of others… Documents supplied to the
tribunal show a clear and consistent pattern of
regulatory abuse: commercial enterprise on land
taxed for farm use; misrepresentation of available
land on license application, disregard of license
limits; failure to adhere to the operating plan, or
to utilize nuisance protocols in the manner
specified by the operating plan; routine commercial
sales of compost, wood chips or in combination with
manure, deliberate disregard of removal order issued
by the CRD. All with an overwhelming impact on
the surrounding properties.”
June 25:
ALC Needs Regulatory Teeth
Thanks to the many who
were able to attend the ALC Appeal Hearing last
week and
show support for the actions of the ALC, the CRD and
our District of Central Saanich – as well as
cheering on our excellent community representatives!
Your applause for our speakers and your restrained,
respectful manner during the presentation by the
spokesperson for the “Central Saanich
Community” (representing the family and friends of
the Appellants) were much appreciated. And we
noted that Mayor Bryson and a number of Councillors
(Cathie Ounsted, Ryan Windsor and Alicia Cormier)
were in attendance for at least part of the
proceedings.
When the Tribunal renders its decision in a
few weeks, it will make one of three determinations:
To uphold the Stop Work Order, to rescind it, or to
refer the Order back to the person who made the
original decision, "with or without directions." The
Commissioners were provided with much indisputable
documentation that the SWO had been issued with
ample cause and that it has been violated regularly
since. The District of Central Saanich’s bylaw
officer confirmed this with an affidavit that
included a detailed log
over 50 pages long
recording the infractions by Stanhope/Foundation
Organics.
A significant portion of the ALC’s time, focus,
staffing and legal resources is being taken up by
this one file. And yet, the three
determinations listed above are all the options open
to the ALC. Why? There's no point to
having rules if they can’t be reasonably monitored
and enforced. Competent teachers and
parents know that the consequences of an unwanted
action must be immediate and appropriate. The
police refer to this as the
broken window syndrome:
We fix the problems when they are small, otherwise
the problems escalate. If the ALC had been
able to clamp down on this commercial operation by
closely monitoring, demanding records and assessing
fines from the very beginning, this case may not
have gone off the rails so badly.
The ALC needs regulatory teeth. Perhaps
there will never again be another egregious outlier but, if there is, the ALC must
be prepared.
June 19:
The ALC Appeal
Hearing
Thank you to the many concerned residents of Tanner
Ridge, Martindale and Hunt Valley for taking the
time to attend the hearing today! You were
treated to an
interesting hearing and
process, and learned even more about the many
issues surrounding Stanhope Farm and their
operation.
We're indebted to our community representatives for
their clear, concise and eloquent speeches.
June 8:
Waiting for the June 19 ALC Appeal Hearing
The ALC received six
intervener applications for its Stop Work Order
(SWO) appeal hearing, and granted them all.
Five of the six intervener groups (the CRD, the
District of Central Saanich, and three community
submissions) take the position that the SWO was
issued for ample just cause and should be upheld.
Our communities’
thanks to those who worked on our various resident
submissions. The Tanner Ridge submission was
fortunate to have had the input and help of a number
of talented people – you know who you are! We
all appreciate the work these people put into
representing the interests of our communities.
May 30: When
Money and Politics Trump Health
Shawnigan Lake residents
have held bottle drives and sock hops to raise
$250,000 to fight a permit to dump contaminated soil
near the watershed that supplies drinking water to
7,000 people. The Cobble Hill community has
dealt with all the adverse effects, familiar to
those who live in the Martindale/Hunt Valley/Tanner
Ridge neighbourhoods, of having a kitchen waste
facility located nearby, plus aquifer safety
concerns. Cobble Hill residents have written
letters, attended meetings, and have even driven
down to Victoria to present their case to the CRD to
bring attention to Saanich’s contract with Fisher
Road Recycling.
Now they’ve been informed that approval has been
given for an almost-doubling of kitchen waste inputs
into their local composting plant. As the CVRD
director for Cobble Hill states:
“It’s unfortunate one
community (Saanich) would sully another because of
poor planning,” and
notes that it’s
“a
situation that’s been troublesome since 2006, but
still the impacts are felt on the community.”
Since
2006!
Don’t communities have the right to clean air, clean
water and the enjoyment of their homes and
properties? How can we stand by and allow
monetary or political interests to trump those
rights? Would any of the other twelve Greater
Victoria municipalities welcome what Cobble Hill and
Central Saanich have gone through?
Would you?
May 28:
Province Upholds Local
Community Rights
It’s official: The
Province won’t step in to the McLoughlin Point
sewage debate. As Minister Polak stated:
“At the
end of the day, it is quite proper for the local
governments, who are elected by their taxpaying
public…to resolve these issues themselves.”
Esquimalt’s Mayor, its Council and the Esquimalt
community have succeeded in stopping Seaterra’s
sewage plan cold. Esquimalt Council listened to its
citizens and took the difficult and courageous path
of putting the interests of its community first.
To quote that famous philosopher, Don Rickles:
"Not everyone's gonna love you. But when
you get a majority on your side, you've got a
chance."
In our own local industrial/commercial kitchen waste
misadventure, the District of Central Saanich
listened to its residents and realized it had the
right and the
obligation to step in
when our wider community’s best interest (in our
case - to clean, healthy air) was threatened, and to
enforce our municipal bylaws. It was - and
continues to be - the right thing to do.
May 24:
North Saanich Joins the Conversation
At its April 7 meeting,
North Saanich Council passed the following
resolution:
"That the District of North Saanich join other
regional municipalities in asking that the CRD be
responsible for the composting of kitchen waste and
consider a site at Hartland landfill or other
equally proximate location in the region."
There's a groundswell of
support for a CRD-run regional facility.
May 18:
When Stink Becomes Air Pollution
One of the requirements
of the CRD’s now-defunct Recycler’s Licence to
Foundation Organics was that odours were not to
extend past the property line of the compost plant.
But instead, the odours created were carried far and
wide by prevailing winds, with the result that the
CRD pulled their composting licence. The CRD's
actions were held to be fair and reasonable by the
B.C. Supreme Court.
But did you know that under the province’s Waste
Management Act, it is prohibited to release
odours that cause pollution? A B.C. court
defined air pollution as
“the presence in the
air of any substance (including odours) that causes
or is capable of causing material physical
discomfort to a person.”
The judge in the case
stressed that it’s not enough that the odour be
unpleasant: The physical discomfort must be
material - it must have physiological
effects such as nausea, gagging, coughing, eyes
watering, headaches or an aggravation of an existing
condition such as asthma.
The
residents of the Martindale, Hunt Valley and Tanner
Ridge communities smelled the stink, identified the
source of the stench, described the odour and many
were made sick by it with - as listed above -
nausea, gagging, coughing, eyes watering, headaches
and aggravation of existing medical conditions,
among other symptoms. The physical discomfort was
most definitely material and, by that court
ruling, this was most definitely
air pollution.
May 14:
Have You Noticed?
Victoria had one of its
best summers
ever
last
year. But if you live anywhere downwind of
Foundation Organics, you likely behaved as if we
were undergoing a nuclear winter: Hunkering
indoors, all windows and doors firmly closed, fans
on for (very warm) air movement, battling any number
of strong physical reactions to the stench, not
wanting to venture out for walks, barbeques, or to
enjoy gardens and decks. The Hunt
Valley/Martindale and Tanner Ridge areas had
arguably the
worst
summer
ever
in 2013.
That makes what’s happening so far this year
striking in its contrast:
It’s
Tuesday, May 13 and I just came back from my second
walk through the neighbourhood in two days with warm
temperatures, clear skies - and no smell - and both
days I have observed more people walking than I did
all of last summer. –
Geppert Family, Tanner Ridge
My husband and I were driving home after being
out for dinner, with car windows down to enjoy the
neighbourhood and the evening air. I noted
that in the last few days we've already had more use and enjoyment of our
neighbourhood, yard and patio than
for ALL of last year.
– Dolores Bell,
Tanner Ridge
It’s mid-May in a new year - a year that we
hope continues to be vastly different (i.e.
vastly better) than the last.
May 9: Is Creating Stink a
Right
on
Farmland?
Farm "aromas" result from
many typical farm activities, as anyone who lives on
farms in the Martindale/Hunt Valley, uses Lochside
Trail, or lives within a kilometre or so of farmland
in the area will know. But even these “normal
farm practices”
don’t
provide an inherent licence to adversely affect
others.
Did you know that B.C.’s Farm Practices Board
has ruled that standard farming practices require
showing consideration for one’s neighbours? As the
Board noted, it
isn’t proper practice
for farmers to run their farms in ways that expose
their neighbours to invasive and overwhelming
odours, and without taking reasonable steps to
mitigate those odours.
And when those odours are persistent and carried a
number of kilometres on prevailing winds - to
Keating, Brentwood Bay, Mount Newton Cross and down
to Elk/Beaver Lakes - as was so often the case with
Foundation Organics' operation, then all those who
were negatively impacted had every right to
complain. A person's right to clean, healthy
air supersedes any perceived right to create stink.
But then, composting on an
industrial scale
was never a "normal farm practice."
May 6:
How to Get
Your Community's Attention
Odour. Smell.
Stink. Stench. Those living anywhere
near Foundation Organics have come to know these
terms and their underlying reality very well. Month
after month of unrelenting stink, odour, smell and
stench did tend to focus and electrify hundreds of
people in our diverse communities.
Did you know that the ability to detect an
odour varies from person to person? This
“skill” can be shaped by how long someone is exposed
to the stink, the intensity of the stench, its
frequency and duration, as well as temperature,
humidity and wind patterns.
Once an odour is concentrated enough to be
recognizable, then we can use subjective descriptors
such as
rancid,
fruity, rotting, putrid, sewage-like, sweet, musty,
etc., as found in the online complaint form set up
by the CRD to handle the flood of odour complaints
about Foundation Organics.
April 30:
Part 2 - Where Do
We Go From Here?
At their April meeting, the CRD Board awarded a
contract to Emterra to haul and process kitchen
waste off-island. But that contract has
flexibility: It allows municipalities to
participate or not, and for shorter periods of time
than to the end of 2015. As Director Ben Isitt
notes:
"I do not
see the city [Victoria] relying on the Emterra
contract after 2014."
CRD Chair and Central
Saanich Mayor Alastair Bryson has revisited the idea
of using Hartland as a temporary solution to the
kitchen waste issue while a more permanent
resolution is found. But not to landfill kitchen
scraps. Instead, he envisions storing
organics
at Harland, and
capturing the resulting methane gas to generate
electricity. This would provide benefits that
relying on the expensive interim contract with
Emterra wouldn't.
http://www.timescolonist.com/news/local/crd-chief-floats-idea-of-burying-food-scraps-at-hartland-1.1004314
In upcoming workshops and meetings, the CRD’s
Environmental Services Committee and CRD staff will
look at alternatives for the disposal of our
region’s kitchen waste. While anticipating
that these workshops and meetings will yield a
number of options, Director Bryson feels that this
Hartland idea should
"receive due consideration again - when the idea
was first suggested by staff, I was more focused on
finding a long-term solution and so gave the idea of
an interim approach less consideration than it
perhaps deserved.
Whether publicly or privately operated, a quality,
long-term approach to processing of diverted
organics will most likely require a significant
capital investment… [An] interim approach may help
us to rationalize the waste stream (both in terms of
quality and quantity) and it would also provide more
time to secure the necessary commitments from
participants to justify the required capital
investment. An interim approach will also allow us
to research what synergies are available if the
Seaterra Resource Recovery Centre is also built at
Hartland in the next few years.”
By putting in place a process that allows
all
options to be presented and discussed, with costs
and other ramifications considered, the CRD should,
we hope, end up with rational interim and
long-term regional plans - and avoid a repetition of
the unfortunate Foundation Organics composting
debacle.
April 24:
Where Do We
Go From Here?
As a result
of the composting debacle following the opening
of Foundation Organics, the CRD has come to
understand that the perfect storm of the wrong
operator using the wrong process in the wrong
location can’t be allowed to happen again.
Been there, done that. If the definition
of insanity is doing the same thing over and
over again and expecting a different result,
then handing kitchen waste back to a private
operator – let alone THIS private operator –
would likely qualify.
In the immediate
short-term, the CRD’s temporary solution has
been the awarding of the contract to Emterra to
haul and process kitchen waste off-island.
But where do we go long-term? Do we build
a composting facility at Hartland? Do we
truck our waste to a reserve on the Malahat?
As the Times Colonist noted in a recent
editorial:
“The CRD staff has
recommended a workshop in the next couple of
months so directors can look at long-term
solutions.
That’s a
good plan, but no workshop will result in any
cheap and easy solutions. We used those up
a long time ago.”
Vic Derman, a Saanich Councillor and a CRD
Environmental Services Committee Director, has
long advocated for technology that makes lasting
sense, both in the process used and as a means
to recover energy from kitchen waste.
Esquimalt Mayor Barb Desjardins, also an ESC
Director, has suggested that the CRD needs to
change its mindset about centralized sewage
treatment and consider building
decentralized
wastewater facilities.
http://www.timescolonist.com/opinion/op-ed/comment-crd-proceeding-without-clear-sewage-plan-1.978858
Perhaps it’s time we re-think the model for
kitchen waste too. Perhaps composting
isn’t the only viable – or even the best -
option. Perhaps it’s time to look at
all
available options, including waste-recovery
technologies.
As Central Saanich resident Carl Eriksen points
out, whichever path we
go down, the CRD must
handle it and not contract it out to private
business, in order to:
1.
Ensure the latest
technology and best practice are implemented.
2.
Avoid having the CRD
being held ransom every time a new contract
would have to be negotiated with a private
operator. It would not be a competitive market
once an operator were selected.
3.
Make sure that, if
the final product is compost, it be made
available locally at a reasonable price.
Mayor/Director Desjardins has urged:
“Pause. Halt.
Stop the spending of the region’s residents’
money until we have a better plan.”
Wise words when dealing with both sewage
and
kitchen waste.
April 19:
Operational Plan NOT Followed
Not only was
Foundation Organics processing far more kitchen
waste than it could use on its own land, but the
CRD’s Qualified Expert (QP) found that the facility
didn’t follow its own Operational Plan, the crucial
underpinning for the granting of its Recycler’s
License.
http://www.courts.gov.bc.ca/jdb-txt/SC/14/00/2014BCSC0085.htm
For example, windrow composting requires the piling
of waste in long rows, which are then turned to
increase oxygen content and feed the aerobic
bacteria that help speed the composting process.
Waste gasses are produced by this method. If
the windrows aren’t properly cured (the time allowed
is too short, or the piles are too wet or too high)
it stinks – and badly.
The QP
found that the windrows at FO were not cured
properly. According to the B.C. Supreme Court
judgement of January 2014, FO
was
given opportunities to make changes to their
operation, but did
not do so, and Tanner
Ridge, Martindale and Hunt Valley residents suffered
the months and months of unrelenting Great
Stink.
April 16:
Too Much Waste
for Too Little Land
The Agricultural Land
Commission supports composting for agricultural use.
Good compost is
important to the regeneration of a farm’s soil,
helping to ensure quality crop production - and the
farm’s viability.
In the case of Foundation Organics’ operation, there
were many issues as identified by Mr. Timmenga, the
CRD’s Qualified Expert (QP) who inspected their
facility.
Chief among the
QP’s findings was that FO accepted larger volumes
than their Recyclers' license allowed.
Given that Central
Saanich requires in its bylaw that 100% of the
compost generated on a farm must be used to
replenish that
same farm’s soil, it
soon became apparent that the size of this farm
couldn’t possibly accommodate all the material being
processed.
April 12:
Our Community Speaks - Again
Our community concerns
were well represented
and some of the viable kitchen waste processsing alternatives were proposed by the
speakers at the CRD Board meeting held April 9.
Here are excerpts from some of the presentations:
Councillor Zeb King
co-wrote an op-ed piece with CRD Director Ben Isitt
for the Times Colonist. As Councillor King
said in his presentation:
"I
am from Central Saanich where the motto on our crest
is that we are 'the land of plenty.' I assure
you that 'the land of plenty' means we have plenty
of farmland, plenty of goodwill and plenty of
patience. That patience has been tested with
the strong stink of kitchen scraps. But we
still come to the region with helpful solutions and
goodwill.
Brenda Antonson:
Since the municipalities have
implemented a costly program to separate kitchen
scraps, it would be a simple matter to keep it
separated at Hartland, capture the [methane] gas and
let it bio-degrade naturally and then retrieve it at
a later date as compost.
Ray Baker:
"The issue is that there was not
a process set up to ensure that food waste compost
would be affordable to a farmer...Let's not move
sideways with a band-aid approach. Let's more
forward to where the puck will be."
Anna Clemente: "Our
neighbours in Martindale and Hunt
Valley have
endured so much more for much longer. Imagine
this on a daily, constant basis - heavy truck
traffic on the Lochside Trail, relentless noise and
alarms from the grinders and fans, dust and litter
with an increased population of rats that have even
spread up to Tanner Ridge...This is a regional issue
and should be administered at a regional level.
The solution is not to transport our kitchen scraps
over the Malahat or to Richmond even on a temporary
basis. We are only shifting the problem to
another community."
Rebecca Cotterell:
"There
are lessons to be learned from the debacle with
Foundation Organics and this instance of private
sector farm composting as a way to manage kitchen
food scraps. As stewards of the public trust,
it is incumbent upon you to recognize a misstep when
it occurs and to reconsider policy when it is not in
the public interest...I think a wise first
step
would be to take the arbitrary effective date of
January 1, 2015 off the table so you can make the
best decision possible rather than the best decision
consistent with that date...Publicly operated
utilities keep bylaw compliance because it is part
of their mandate."
Ken Marriette:
"On the
positive side, I think we have all learned where NOT
to place a food scraps waste program...There's a
local company whose slogan is 'Do it Once - Do it
Right.' Well, the opportunity was clearly
missed to do it right the first time."
Councillor Cathie Ounsted spoke
as a Central Saanich resident: "I think
the ban of January 2015 was premature without proper
facilities in place...I urge you to find a
well-thought-out, permanent regional solution to
composting...Please do not come up with a knee-jerk
solution that will not fit the bill for our
long-term needs, keeping in mind to check the boxes
on the three-pillar analysis of environmental,
social and economic responsibilities to our
communities."
Councillor Ryan Windsor also spoke as a
community member:
"I’m here
to express my own concerns with regard to the
ongoing debate regarding an in-region solution as
part of the Regional Kitchen Scraps Strategy. As you
heard earlier today, the District of Central Saanich
Council passed motions resulting in letters in
September 2013 and again in January asking the CRD
to make space available at the Hartland Landfill
site for kitchen scraps processing. It appears
despite that first letter some 8 months ago little
progress has been made on potentially implementing a
site at Hartland Landfill."
April 6:
Paying
the Price in Yet Another Way
Taxes in Central Saanich
are going up: Residential properties will pay
3.11 percent more in 2014, about $50. more per
household. Some department budgets are
actually down: Police services, engineering,
public works and transportation services.
What’s costing more? Our bylaw enforcement
department budget is up by over $192,000. Speaks
volumes about the further - financial - burden we
all carry when our bylaws aren't respected.
April 4:
History Repeats
Our neighbours in Cobble
Hill are experiencing many of the same issues with
their compost facility, Fisher Road Recycling, as
we’ve endured with Foundation Organics.
Unfortunately, they’ve been dealing with their
problem for at least
12 years.
Their composting facility is located on industrial,
not agricultural land, but otherwise their fight
seems really familiar.
http://vancouverisland.ctvnews.ca/video?clipId=1024490
Their community held a heated three-hour public
hearing earlier this week, packing their local hall.
According to residents who attended, not a
single voice was raised in support of expanding the
nearby compost facility, as has been requested by
the company.
Based on our experience here in Central Saanich, we
can certainly understand their concerns about odour,
water and air quality, and vermin.
And now the residents are concerned that Esquimalt
may also elect to partner with Saanich and send
waste to Cobble Hill.
That community of 7,000 is asking that it not become
Greater Victoria’s garbage dump.
But wait, there's more: Are you aware that the
Shawnigan Lake community is concerned about a major
risk to their public water supply?
South Island Aggregates has a Ministry of
Environment permit to build a “remediation facility”
for 100,000 tonnes of contaminated soil a year, much
of it to come from Greater Victoria, in a quarry in
the headwaters of the Shawnigan Lake watershed.
That community is asking that it not become Greater
Victoria’s toxic waste dump.
April 2:
How Bad a Smell,
Really?
If you don’t live in the
Central Saanich areas affected by the Foundation
Organics commercial composting operation, you might
not be aware of how nasty the stink was throughout
last summer, into the fall and December - and even
at times this year.
A massive stink cloud was carried on prevailing
winds that would blanket the Tanner Ridge community
or shift and hit Keating and even carry into
Brentwood. At times, the stench was evident as
far north as Mount Newton or down into the Elk and
Beaver Lake areas. Other times, the major
residential areas were spared while the Martindale
and Hunt Valley communities were choked out.
The stench has been so bad that over 2,000
formal complaints have been filed with the CRD, as
well as the many hundreds of complaints to the
Municipality and to the Agricultural Land
Commission. Residents report they have
experienced coughing fits, burning of eyes and nasal
passages, worsening of existing health conditions
(asthma, cancer, immune system issues), and worry
about long-term effects of the off-gassing.
One’s home is supposedly one’s castle but in
the affected areas, hundreds of residents spent what
was arguably the best summer on record as
prisoners in their homes, unable to open
windows and doors or enjoy their gardens and decks.
As CTV News reporter Stephanie Sherlock
acknowledged on-air on August 23,
“If you haven’t been out
to Central Saanich to experience the smell, it is
truly, overwhelmingly putrid.”
Really.
The Issues
1. The composting facility was a non-farm use of
agricultural land, as determined by the Agricultural Land Commission.
2. Foundation Organics operated as a commercial, industrial
facility, yet was paying farm taxes.
3. This industrial business was sited in a busy
farm/residential/recreational area.
4. All compost generated must be used to enrich the soil on
the farm, not sold. One of the Municipality's lawsuits
claims that compost was sold in contravention of bylaws.
5.
The amount of kitchen waste FO handled was beyond what would have been
needed for their farm's land area and nutrient requirements.
6. Foundation Organics wanted to almost double the amount of waste it
was legally allowed to
handle.
7. Putrid odours extended well beyond the waste facility's
boundaries and were often unrelenting.
8. Many people became ill. Were we safe?
9. Hundreds of residents lost the enjoyment of their homes and
properties for most of last year.
10. Significant rat infestations were reported.
11. The facility continued to operate in spite of the CRD license
suspension.
12. As well as the CRD's kitchen scraps, Foundation Organics hauled
waste from restaurants, grocery stores and cruise ships into our local community.
13. Four lawsuits are pending.
It's Been a
Massive
Stink Cloud!
Originally
the Cloud of Compost Stink was thought to be more confined
(see image below.)
We
now know from resident reports that prevailing winds carried the putrid stench
even into Brentwood, up to Mount Newton and south to Elk/Beaver Lakes
and even Royal Oak, affecting
many thousands of people.
Rats and Compost:
Another Pesky Issue
Jan. 22, 2014:
A Central Saanich Road homeowner reports
that in the six years he's lived here, he's never had rats in
his home. But that changed recently as he had to pay an
exterminator to kill 5 large rats and chase a sixth rat away.
Jan. 21:
More reports of rat sightings and
trappings in the Tanner Ridge neighbourhood, in what appears to
be a significant infestation.
Dec. 13:
It seems that the area continues to
be plagued by rats. As neighbours report: The rats
are looking for more food and one neighbour trapped four in just
three days. There are more yet, given the continued
droppings.
Oct.
12: A
couple of days ago, Liz Curnow on Rey Road asked, “Do
you know if anyone is having a problem with rats? We
have for the last few years and it is increasing -
caught 5 in two days this week in our garden.
Not
sure if this is related but highly coincidental - be
interesting to see if
anyone else is having a similar problem. Our
immediate neighbour also has rats.”
To which a number of others have
responded:
"Yes, we have had more rats this year than I can remember."
“Yes, we have put out our traps again this fall and we have
caught 3 this week. I almost hate to admit it but we have
caught a significant number over the last couple of years.
Not pleasant.”
“YES, we have had rats in our garden/backyard since
last year. My husband has several mouse traps out and we get
one every week at least.”
What
could possibly have caused a rat infestation in our
communities? Couldn't have been the new, putrid supply of food
that was so easily available, could it?
Contacts:
Russ
Smith
rsmith@crd.bc.ca
Senior Manager
CRD Environmental Resource
M
anagement
Colin Fry
colin.fry@gov.bc.ca
Director, Agricultural Land Commission
Shirley Bond
JTST.Minister@gov.bc.ca
Minister of Tourism
Norm
Letnick
AGR.Minister@gov.bc.ca
Minister of Agriculture
Terry Lake
HLTH.health@gov.bc.ca
Minister of Health
Not
Breathing is
NOT
an Option
Families in our
neighbourhoods, like this one, deserve to enjoy their
homes and gardens. Being forced to live indoors
all year round, with doors and windows shut, is not
acceptable.
Featuring
Peninsula Gems
Marsh Farm
Location: 7337 Wallace Dr.
Open: Tuesday to Sunday
Just three years ago, Evelyn Marsh created a beautiful
organic farm on her 2.5 acres of land.
Visit her extensive
gardens of raised beds to see a large array of
vegetables, herbs and berries.
You’ll enjoy the gentle
walk as you pick the produce you want – that’s the
ultimate in fresh! – or you can see what’s fresh-picked
in the farm’s cooler. And, if you
have mobility issues, not to worry:
Evelyn
provides a couple of golf carts for easy access,
allowing customers to drive between the raised beds and
reach all the crops.
It doesn’t
get much better than this!
The Lochside Trail, Michell Farms and Winkel’s Pig
Farm
We’re blessed to have the multi-use Lochside Trail
so nearby. This great, flat trail provides for
a beautiful ride, walk, run or stroll through the
fields and farms of our rural peninsula.
And what better
place to visit while on the trail than
Michell Farms?
Location: 2451
Island View Rd.
Open: Daily, all year
We recall that Vern Michell
turned down the lucrative Saanich kitchen waste
contract last year, opting to keep farming, doing
what his family has done so well for six
generations.
This family-run operation encompasses hundreds of
acres, and provides a wide variety of fresh produce
and fruit, as well as their own grass-raised beef,
making it a popular stop on the Trail, or as a
shopping destination. The Michells also
provide a field for the use of model-airplane
enthusiasts.
Michell Farms deserves
our thanks and our support: Shop Locally!
And as you go further south
on the Trail, at 6505 Lochside, you’ll see
Winkel’s Pig Farm,
a popular attraction.
There you’ll be treated to pigs enjoying the Trail
from their side of the fence. If the pigs aren’t in
their roadside pen, they may be in the barn having
their piglets.
Silver Rill Farm
Location:
7117 Central Saanich Rd.
Open:
Daily, June to end-October, 9 -6
The
go-to name for fresh, sweet corn on the Peninsula
is, arguably, the Fox family’s Silver Rill Farm.
They tell us that this year they planted 37
varieties of corn!
Three
generations of this farm family have provided our
communities with fresh-picked corn and a variety of
vegetables and berries.
Shop
locally!
De Vine
Vineyards
Location: 6181
Old West Saanich Rd.
Open: Daily in the summer to
the end of September - Weekdays 12 p.m. to 5 p.m.
Weekends 11 a.m. to 6 p.m.
From October on: Weekends only.
The Windsor family bought 24 acres on Old West
Saanich Road in 2007 and created the beautiful
grounds, vineyard, winery and tasting room now on
display.
Enjoy a glass of Pinot Gris, Syrah or Pinot Noir on
their large patio and take in the panoramic view
overlooking farmland, Mt. Baker and the Islands.
Or try their
Grüner Veltliner,
an unusual Austrian white wine grape variety.
This family of risk-takers is always looking to
expand their offerings.
Watch for the
addition of food options later this year.
Our area of the
Peninsula has returned to being a terrific place to
live, play and shop!
Did You Know?
Mar. 27:
When A Stop Work Order Doesn't Mean Much
On Tuesday, in spite of
the Stop Work Order, the roads around
Stanhope/Foundation Organics saw a lot of traffic
and mess as trucks took in fill – in quantities that
appear to be well over the ALC’s stated fill limit,
and likely not allowed under Central Saanich bylaws.
Neighbours took
many photos and reported the scope of the traffic
and the fill to the government agencies involved in
this ongoing and mind-boggling tale.
There have been
many protestations by the compost facility's
spokespeople that the rules
were
followed, that they
have been
- and
are - complying with
regulations, that this sorry mess is
not
of
their making. Yet these credible,
on-the-ground reports continue to contradict these
claims.
Mar. 21:
A Must-Watch - Deja Vu from 2010
Stanhope Dairy Farm sold
its milk quota in 2009 in preparation for going into
the composting business. Their new operation,
Foundation Organics, was sited on that former dairy
farm land - as a commercial, industrial operation on
agricultural land,
paying farm taxes.
Nice perk if you can get it!
Some would have us believe that all was well with
this business until pampered elites on Tanner Ridge
started to complain in
2013
about what the facility
operators say should
have been taken as normal farm smells.
Well, maybe not.
This news item from
November 2010,
years before Tanner Ridge residents organized to
protect their air quality, health and property
values, clearly shows that the same problems existed
from the very beginning, just affecting a smaller
number of people - Foundation Organics' neighbouring
farmers and other residents in the
Martindale and Hunt Valley areas. Not
until 2013 did anyone pay attention to
their
suffering.
Farm Compost Facility
Has Nearby Neighbours Steaming
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CpkYce3Lq3w
Mar. 19:
"Just
a Few" Residents Affected - NOT!
Last
August, two residents mounted a campaign to petition
Premier Christy Clark to intervene in what had
become a quality of life, health and environmental
crisis for our communities. Sanda and Dan
Gheorghiu, over just a few days of door-knocking and
liasing with neighbours, collected
262
signatures
of people who were badly affected by the "obnoxious
by-products" from the commercial composting plant
sited on nearby Stanhope Farm.
The
couple ended their time-consuming drive, deciding
they had enough signatures to get the Premier's
attention.
And the Premier's
response?
She informed the
petitioners of what they already knew: That the CRD
had suspended the Foundation Organics composting
license earlier that month.
Too bad that hadn't
changed anything for the 262 petitioners and for the
hundreds more who never had the opportunity to sign.