December 2013
Dec. 25: Composter Under Fire
Again
http://www.vicnews.com/neighbourhoods/sidney/237180431.html
Dec. 24:
Central Saanich Composting Company Charged Sued
http://www.timescolonist.com/opinion/central-saanich-composting-company-charged-sued-1.770099
Dec. 23: Anna Clemente with Al
Ferraby (start at 19:50)
http://www.cfax1070.com/Media/CFAX-Podcasts/Mornings-with-Al-Ferraby/December-23-2013-8am
November 2013
What a Great Community!
A huge Thank You to everyone who endured the long days in court as we showed our support for the CRD's suspension of Foundation Organic's licence. Now we wait to see how the judge will rule.
Encouraging News
But meanwhile we're seeing a positive result of our community's attendance and lobbying at the CRD’s Environmental Services Committee meetings. At next Wednesday's ESC meeting, the committee will look at how to possibly integrate kitchen and sewage wastes.
If the Directors take this route, we’ll have gone a long way
to resolving our Great Stink problem.
But this CRD committee isn’t united and its staff hasn’t presented all options in the past. We have some friends on the committee, and they need our support. The other directors need to see that we’re paying attention. Only our community’s continued commitment and attendance can help keep our best interests in front of the ESC.
It’s All About Keeping Up the Pressure
Protecting our interests isn’t what government does best, but we can help politicians and bureaucrats to make the right decisions. And that help involves our time. We aren’t paid to do this, we may be feeling defeated by it, we may resent it, but the reality is that without an active, vocal, engaged population, we won’t win.
See the ESC meeting details below.
We can’t do this without you.
October 2013
CRD Committee of the Whole Meeting October 30th
What Was the Outcome?
The CRD Committee of the Whole meeting began at 9:30 a.m. and
ended after 3 p.m. including time for a lunch break. That’s a
lot of discussion about whether to rescind the biosolids ban!
After listening to 15 presentations from the public (more on
this later) and three presentations from “experts,” the
Directors decided that the biosolids ban stays in place for now,
with a motion by Director Vic Derman, and supported by the
majority of the Directors, to require public consultation before
lifting the ban. There was also a motion by Director Barb
Desjardins to task CRD staff with studying the integration of
management of both waste streams, and that report will go before
the Environmental Services Committee. The meeting where this
report is presented will be an important one for our community
to attend. Details as they become available.
Yesterday’s outcome was heartening. Our thanks to those in our
community, including our MLA Gary Holman, who attended the
meeting: Politicians notice when the gallery is filled. And
thanks to those who wrote to the Directors. Many of the
Directors seem to be hearing our concerns, and we now appear to
have a (growing) number of friends among them.
What Got our Attention?
If you weren’t there, you missed some interesting theatre! Of
the 15 initial presenters, 13 were local residents who have skin
in the game, and who implored the CRD to hold firm on the ban.
The other two speakers weren’t residents – they were “experts”
brought in to promote the application of biosolids to land. One
of the speakers, Sally Brown (who received such great press in
Tuesday’s Times Colonist), is a resident of Washington State and
was invited by the Seaterra Commission, which paid her expenses.
To pay to lobby our Directors is questionable enough as a policy
for a public body such as Seaterra, but to then have her speak
as a private citizen was over the top. The other non-resident
speaker works with Sylvis, a consulting firm in New Westminster.
Environmental Services
Committee
Several members of the
CRD's Environment Committee appear willing to back away
from deadlines for diverting kitchen scraps out of the
landfill.
Board Chair Alastair Bryson is one of them..“So, I think
we’re artificially pressing ourselves into a timeline”
The problem is lack of facilities for recycling kitchen
scraps, which a growing number of municipalities are
collecting separately from the garbage. The CRD is
planning to impose a surcharge on the landfilling of
that material early next year, which Bryson says is
unfair so long as there isn't an alternative place to
take it.
As to what the alternative should be...a packed public
gallery urged the committee to approve building a
CRD-owned-and-operated compost facility rather than
seeking another private operator. There's no
decision on that issue. The committee meeting ran
overtime and has been adjourned indefinitely.
Oct. 22:
Michell Pulls Out; Saanich Looking at Other Bidders
http://www.timescolonist.com/news/maintain-planned-2015-ban-on-food-scraps-at-hartland-landfill-crd-directors-urged-1.667439
Oct. 18: Regulators
Respond to Compost Concerns
http://www.vicnews.com/neighbourhoods/sidney/228402831.html
Oct. 18:
The Stink is here again today and
it's "truly overwhelmingly putrid." Keep filling out those
online complaint forms. Maybe we'll break 2000 complaints!
Also, FO neighbours report that the "pet lady" may still be
operating out of Stanhope. She was apparently issued two
fines by Central Saanich yesterday.
Oct. 12:
Tanner residents report they were able to buy what was
apparently represented as FO compost at Aces, and they claim
they were offered a custom mix because Aces could simply bring
in a truckload from FO. They were also informed that
FO's prices had come down...
Oct. 16:
CRD Rejects Composter's Appeal
http://www.vicnews.com/neighbourhoods/sidney/228099871.html
Oct. 16:
Can Compost in Central Saanich be
Stink Free?
http://vancouverisland.ctvnews.ca/video?clipId=1024490
Oct. 15:
FO Lawyer Puts Blame on CRD and
Central Saanich
http://www.cfax1070.com/Media/CFAX-Podcasts/Frank-Stanford/October-15-2013-9am
Oct. 14:
Richard Atwell of Stop a Bad Plan
http://www.cfax1070.com/Media/CFAX-Podcasts/Ian-Jessop/October-14-2013-1pm
Oct. 12:
Central
Saanich Compost Scrap Likely Bound for Courtroom
http://www.timescolonist.com/central-saanich-compost-scrap-likely-bound-for-courtroom-1.657802
Oct. 11:
Apology Letter Is Unwelcome
http://www.vicnews.com/neighbourhoods/sidney/227312761.html
http://www.cfax1070.com/Media/CFAX-Podcasts/Ian-Jessop/October-9-2013-2pm
Oct. 6:
Compost Stink Jeopardizes
Five-Year, $4.7- million Deal to Process Food Scraps
http://www.timescolonist.com/news/compost-stink-jeopardizes-five-year-4-7-million-deal-to-process-food-scraps-1.650437
Oct. 11:
The CRD denied Foundation Organics' appeal.
The CRD's Larisa Hutcheson found that:
FO received "in excess of the maximum annual quantities of feedstock expected;
Fo operated "in a manner that creates odours that constitute a public nuisance;
A total of 1412 odour complaints were received by the CRD;
FO had material "that has not finished composting and is not cured sufficiently;" and
FO operated "contrary to an approved Operation Plan."
FO has been ordered to remove all existing compost from within their building by October 25.
Reaction:
Oct. 11:
"Horaaaah!
It's been a long hard journey! Thank you for all your
support Tanner Ridge!"
Burton & Cheryl Cummings
Oct. 16:
Being the district/field
Environmental Health Officer for Central Saanich and more recently
stepping into my current role, as the Regional Built Environment
Consultant, I have heard the concerns from residents from some time,
have attended the site area, met with the neighbours, been liaising
with all of the agencies, and driven through the Tanner Ridge
community on many an occasion. It is my sincerest hope that
we, all of us together, may pave the way for future collaboration
amongst the agencies and the public. So that what has happened
in your community doesn’t happen to others.
Jade Yehia
Oct. 16:
Over 120 residents attended the Central Saanich
Committees Meeting yesterday evening. They were joined by
Dr. Murray Fyfe and Jade Yehia from Island Health, Larisa
Hutcheson and Russ Smith from the CRD, and Colin Fry from the
ALC. The two-hour meeting was ably chaired by Councillor
Cathie Ounsted.
A representative from each agency made a short presentation,
followed by many questions from the audience. It was
amazing to see all these agencies gathered together in one room
to meet with our community.
Each agency outlined their steps to address our concerns and
discussed how they'll come up with frameworks to stop this
situation from happening again.
Island Health
is looking at developing partnerships to conduct air quality
testing. The CRD is considering changing
the licence approval process to include a thorough review of any
proposed operating plan by the CRD's own qualified professional, as
well as referring
composting applications to the
ALC and the Municipality to ensure the applicant would be in
compliance with those agencies' bylaws and regulations. The
ALC's Colin Fry took personal responsibility
and stated that "some things slipped through the cracks" but that
he's made this issue his "singular priority" and we can expect a
decision by the ALC by the end of this week or into next week.
This was potentially great
news.
And a take-away: Good things happen when there's
discussion and collaboration with the community. In a
perfect world, these agencies will learn from this experience
and apply those learnings going forward.
Our community's
thanks go to the stalwarts who attended this meeting and other
meetings, and who wrote the letters and made the calls and
presentations.
Your support - in whatever form it's taken - has been crucial to getting us
here.
Congratulations for standing up for your community!
Reaction:
"A very
good meeting, very informative and gives us more hope to win this
war, Let's keep fighting and thanks to all 'our' speakers as well.
VIHA (Island health) finally came out of the cupboard but we weren't
that impressed with their view."
Doug & Joyce
Clements
Oct. 12:
Back
in 2009 and 2010 the CRD paid for and received reports on the issue of
integrating planning for organics, biosolids and municipal solid
waste in recognition that this would be "required to optimize
resource management in the CRD over the long term."
At that time, consultants reported that "household organics could be
co-digested with the wastewater sludge to produce fuel substitutes
and carbon offsets. The end product would be incinerated as a fuel
for cement kilns."
In fact, Larisa Hutcheson signed a report stating, "Clearly,
planning for core area area wastewater and regional solid waste must
move forward in an integrated way... An integrated
planning approach may reveal synergies that could result in reduced
life-cycle costs for infrastructure, more flexible
options, reduced greenhouse gas emissions and other environmental
benefits, as well as new revenue streams from
recovered resources."
Four years have passed, Central Saanich
has suffered in the meantime, and we're still waiting for the CRD to
look at the long term picture.
Look particularly at the diagram on page 3 of this first report -
showing how organics could be diverted away from composting and
into anaerobic digestion treatment instead:
http://crd.bc.ca/reports/corearealiquidwastem_/2009_/
06june24_/2009june24item02ehq0/2009june24item02ehq0.pdf
http://crd.bc.ca/reports/corearealiquidwastem_
/2010_/10october27_2010oct27jointesccal/2010oct27jointesccal.pdf
http://crd.bc.ca/reports/corearealiquidwastem_/2010_/
11november24_/2010nov24item10amoti/2010nov24item10amoti.pdf
Oct. 8:
An appeal to the BC Ombudsman regarding
the lack of response or action by the ALC has been submitted by Dave
Bond and a
case file has been assigned. The investigative process now
begins. This appeal claims that the ALC has failed to fulfill
its mandate, to enforce its Regulations, and has ignored or delayed
responding to complaints.
In order for Dave to prepare for more
questions by the Ombudsman's office: If you have evidence of
your communication with the ALC that was not answered, please
forward your information to Dave at:
mdbond@shaw.ca
Oct. 8: About
130 residents attended yesterday evening's Council Meeting to ask
that our local representatives stay the course when dealing with
Stanhope Farms. The attendees
seemed
underwhelmed by the
letter of apology.
"I just wanted to congratulate everyone on another fine
showing of how committed we are. We demonstrated
that residents do not want to back away from the
upcoming court issue. Now it's time to write
letters to the Mayor and Council [commenting on the
Stanhope letter]. Let's not forget that the CRD
was also sent a copy. We should be writing to the
CRD as well."
Ray Baker
Oct. 8:
Are you getting The Stench today?
If so, you may be interested to know that neighbours of FO report
that the "pet lady" is apparently still making frequent trips in and
out of Stanhope Farms. And the Organico vans are often seen
using Old East Road in what appears to be the dropping off of food
waste. As one resident writes, if this is the case, it "sure
exposes the lie in their apology."
Oct. 7:
As the wind is changing for the fall, it
is blowing north now and the past two days have been bad. I
wrote an email to the Mayor about it and pointed out that the Rendle
family must be either not interested in cleaning up the air or they
don't have the expertise or the funds to do the job. Why else
would they not take this time to make sure there would be no odour
and no complaints?
Would "Going-It-Alone" Saanich
Put Up With This Mess?
http://www.timescolonist.com/news/local/compost-stink-jeopardizes-five-year-4-7-million-deal-to-process-food-scraps-1.650437
Oct. 6: "Saanich Mayor
Frank Leonard said if Michell decides not to sign a contract,
the district would have to look at either re-tendering or doing
the processing itself. 'But we'd have to have a location
and logistics and public consultation,' he said."
Imagine! What novel concepts -
planning and consultation. And we strongly suggest the
Blenkinsop Valley would provide many good industrial, commercial
composting locations. Just trying to be helpful...
Is Foundation Organics
the Only Smelly Operation?
Oct. 12: In
a news article in the Times Colonist this week the owner of
Zero Net waste Composting in Abbotsford says that they are
managing to compost 11,000 tons of "garbage" without any
odour issues and that composting is getting unfair press
because of facilities such as Foundation Organics. He agrees
that no one should have to suffer the obnoxious odours that
we experienced this summer.
He suggests that Net Zero operates odour-free. I find this
amazing in view of the fact that 11,000 tons of stinky,
oozing masses of rotting food wastes are being dumped into a
building to be transformed into "black gold." Do his
neighbours share his view? We have been told by the
owner of the facility in Nanaimo that they run stench-free,
however the neighbours are complaining. In Alberta, the
facility located approximately 10 miles from Edmonton gets
complaints from their suburb, Sherwood Park, when nasty
smells drift their way, but all the while the operators take
credit for running the best, state-of-the-art facility
possible. So excuse me if I harbor doubts that garbage
management located close to residences doesn't stink.
Brenda Antonson
Couldn't
Happen - Or Could It?
Much has been said about the commercial,
industrial, private composting facility in Central
Saanich and rightly so. I want to bring to your
attention a point that, to the best of my knowledge, has
not been made before.
If the CRD decides to rely on private operators to
process the green waste, that will leave the taxpayers
financially vulnerable. At best, it is likely only a
small handful of private operators will enter the
market. Picture the day the CRD has more than 30,000
tons of green garbage to get rid of and is faced with
the reality of having to negotiate with a few colluding
operators. Is it not entirely possible those for-profit
operators would be able to hold the CRD to ransom? The
taxpayers are only protected if there is competition in
the market place.
Conclusion: The CRD needs to establish its own
composting facility.
Carl Eriksen
September 2013
Sept. 26:
Compost
Conundrum Keeps Neighbours Fuming
http://www.ctvnews.ca/video?clipId=1012323
Sept. 26:
Michell Family Considering Cancelling Saanich Contract
http://www.cheknews.ca/index.php?bckey=AQ~~,AAAA4mHNTzE~,ejlzBnGUUKY1gXVPwEwEepl35Y795
rND&bclid=975107450001&bctid=2698416830001
Sept. 26:
Anna Clemente
& Brenda Antonson Interview - starts 6:00 min. in
http://www.cfax1070.com/Media/CFAX-Podcasts/Frank-Stanford/September-26-2013-1pm
Sept. 26:
Alastair Bryson Interview - starts 21:00 min. in
http://www.cfax1070.com/Media/CFAX-Podcasts/Mornings-with-Al-Ferraby/September-26-2013-8am
Sept. 25: Barb
Desjardins heard the citizens of Central Saanich
http://stopabadplan.ca/media/130925_CFAX_Barb_Desjardins.m4a
Sept. 25:
Nils Jensen,
Chair Environmental Services Committee followed by
John Alexander, Lawyer for Foundation Organics -
starts 5:15 min. in for Jensen;
22:00 min. in for Alexander
http://www.cfax1070.com/Media/CFAX-Podcasts/Stephen-Andrew/September-25-2013-9am
Sept. 25: CRD to Look for Compost
Alternatives
http://www.ctvnews.ca/video?clipId=1011450
Sept. 25: CRD
Environmental Services Committee Meeting; Saanich Mayor "Goes It Alone" with Michell Farms
http://www.cheknews.ca/index.php?bckey=AQ~~,AAAA4mHNTzE~,ejlzBnGUUKY1gXVPwEwEepl35Y795rND&bclid
=975107450001&bctid=26958418090
Sept. 25:
CRD Environmental Services Committee
Delegate Rebecca Cotterell:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EkvLhchuEqU&hd=1
Delegate Brenda Antonson:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CuzIq0fstdQ&hd=1
Delegate Anna Clemente:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Pck6rVcvcp0&hd=1
Councillor Cathie Ounsted:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dBYbjOByHEU&hd=1
Director Vic Derman:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QkKwdssIubI&hd=1
Director Barb Desjardins:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q_Cf6is4MqA&hd=1
Director Wendal Milne:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1GnkC69Ssss
Close to 100 residents took time out of their work or
home life to attend the CRD’s Environmental Services Committee
meeting. A number of CRD Directors expressed
sympathy for the plight of Central Saanich residents and about the
unintended consequences of the CRD’s decision to issue private
recycler licences.
Barbara Desjardins of Esquimalt asked the Committee to refrain
from applying more bandaid solutions to the issue of waste
management, asking for a policy that was long-term and good for the
entire region. Wendal Milne of Sooke stated that
he considered the CRD to have been “hellbent” in its actions, and
Vic Derman of Saanich spoke of how unacceptable is the situation in
Central Saanich, and how this has been a failure of decision-making.
He spoke of gasification and the benefits of an integrated
approach to dealing with all waste materials. And Dean
Fortin of Victoria, stating that it is “inappropriate to continue
with the facility in Central Saanich,” asked staff present to follow
the money trail.
The Committee voted to keep
trucking waste upisland and to Hartland, if needed, until their
next meeting on October 23.
Could the CRD build a proper,
state-of-the-art waste composting facility at Hartland – a site
already in use, with its established truck traffic and noise - and
make money? The quality of the compost would be
guaranteed by a public facility, and the CRD could make money
selling that clean compost to farms, garden centres and other
outlets. Now there’s a plan whose time has come!
Sept. 25: Town
Hall Meeting
Video at:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IEWDdbhTA4Q
Filmed & edited for time by
friends of Stop the Stink, Richard & Ed
Close to 300 Central Saanich residents
attended the Town Hall Meeting at Keating Elementary.
The overflow crowd asked many probing questions of our Mayor
and the five Councillors who attended. Councillor
Zeb King ably moderated the Town Hall, and suggestions from
residents were noted for consideration by our municipality.
A number of interesting points:
Mayor Bryson clearly stated that the compost plant is “not
accessory to farm use” but an actual business on farm land.
The ALC was pointed to again and again as needing to be at
the table; so far the ALC has continued to postpone its
determination of whether this waste business is a valid farm
activity, and our Councillors, notably Ryan Windsor, are frustrated
in attempts to get ALC’s Colin Fry and Ron McLeod to join in the
Multi-Agency Meeting with residents, now rescheduled to October 15.
Also frustrating was the silence of Dr.
Richard Stanwick on the health issues residents have notified him
about. Our Mayor wrote to VIHA (now Island
Health) about our health concerns, and contrary to news reports,
stated that VIHA had not been told by Central Saanich that
there weren’t any health worries. Mayor
Bryson and Council were urged to pressure Island Health to do air
quality testing.
Suspension News
"There
was a hearing held ... regarding the license
suspension [of Foundation Organics.] The results of the
hearing will likely not be known until early October. In the
meantime, the conditional suspension regarding acceptance and
processing of food waste will remain in place."
-
Russ Smith, Senior Manager, CRD Environmental Resource
Management
Sept. 26: It's been
confirmed by neighbours of the plant that food waste apparently
continues to be accepted at that site, in spite of the
suspension. Organico, a company in which the waste
operators have ownership, was observed delivering there
yesterday.